What Reddit is saying about programmatic seo

Where programmatic seo comes up

A sample of 10 posts

The highest scoring of the newest 50 posts that match, each with the start of the post and its top reply. The full list, every comment and anything older need a key.

1. I honestly don’t understand how people are growing new websites through SEO anymore.

   I’ve spent around 2 months building a site from scratch. A lot of the work was not just “generate pages with AI and publish”. I collected the data, structured it properly, worked on speed, fixed...

   Top reply (14 points): is this the new wave of 'SEO experts'. Moaning on Reddit that their 2 months (yes 2 MONTHS) worth of work isn't competing against sites that have been on...

   r/WebsiteSEO57 points96 comments19 d ago
2. 200 000 Backlinks from just 50 Referring Domains - How is this not getting penalized?

   I’ve been researching a company in Europe that operates around 40–50 lead generation websites, each targeting a different service industry, such as cleaning, carpentry, painting, plumbing, etc....

   Top reply (1 points): Because they’re spammy. Anyone can link to anyone. Google just ignores it and doesn’t pass the value.

   r/WebsiteSEO11 points12 comments10 d ago
3. AI+Programmatic SEO still works for AdSense in 2026

   !img New website. English & Spanish conent. Drop domain. AI Generated content. Around 350 pages (Programmatic SEO). 1st - attempt. Voilà

   Top reply (3 points): But the earnings will not be same as before

   r/Adsense10 points16 comments17 d ago
4. from 437 to 1,570 clicks from Google/AI in a month

   I have claude code running on a vps with scheduled routines. they write blog posts, build small free tools and generate programmatic pages my part is about 30 minutes a week reviewing... search...

   Top reply (1 points): That 13 posts to 30 clicks ratio is brutal but I wouldn't delete them, just move the tool link to the first screen of every one of those posts. Right now...

   r/GrowthHacking10 points9 comments8 d ago
5. How do you decide which keywords to target with programmatic SEO?

   Top reply (1 points): I’d start with search intent and scalability, not just keyword volume. For programmatic SEO, the best keywords usually follow repeatable patterns like “best...

   r/AISEOTricks9 points13 comments20 d ago
6. How can I rank a business in the UAE when the business is based in India and has no physical address there?

   Hey everyone, I have a question about SEO, and I would really appreciate some advice from people who have experience with international SEO. Currently, I am doing SEO for a client whose business...

   Top reply (2 points): Without a UAE address the map pack is mostly off the table, so I'd focus on regular organic results and set expectations around that. What usually moves it...

   r/digital_marketing9 points12 comments12 d ago
7. I built FootVal: my own transfer-value model for 11k footballers, plus live scores and an MCP server so Claude/ChatGPT can use it

   Hey r/SideProject, Since June I've been building FootVal (footval.com), a football (soccer) site that puts its own price on every player and shows where it disagrees with the market. What it does...

   Top reply (3 points): The 'our value vs market' idea is clear once I read the explanation, but I'd put the comparison and the reason for the gap right on the player page. 'We...

   r/SideProject9 points9 comments12 d ago
8. Anyone else feel like their site is unfairly judged by GoogleBot based on this explosion of slop sites?

   Relatively new to SEO here, so be kind... I'm a senior software engineer with a ton of practical web experience (having built sites with search engine friendly / accessible HTML) and what I...

   Top reply (4 points): Sounds like an authority issue. ie, more links to your site are needed to convince Google you’re an authority. (Links from websites that rank for real...

   r/SEO7 points28 comments16 d ago
9. I need some help. I can't figure out whether my site has been hit by an algorithmic penalty or if it's simply too new and needs more time.

   Hello. A question for WebLinkr and other SEO professionals. Could you please explain what you mean by scaled content? Do you mean creating hundreds of pages in a single day using programmatic SEO,...

   Top reply (1 points): Your post/comment has been removed because your account has a low CQS Score. Please contribute more positively on Reddit overall before posting. Cheers :D I...

   r/SEO7 points26 comments8 d ago
10. After publicly diagnosing a lot of sites in this sub, the single most common problem isn't what beginners think it is

    I’ve written long public diagnoses on roughly 40 sites in this sub over the past couple of months. Hair extensions e-commerce, educational simulations, Italian insurance content, Minecraft tool...

    Top reply (1 points): I agree that strategic misalignment is often overlooked. Many websites focus too much on technical SEO while ignoring search intent, competitor authority,...

    r/SEO_Xpert7 points5 comments8 d ago